How to checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups

 




 titles about how to get the important to track a dangerous MLM group that does not pay its patent and check if the public company was partnered with others:

How to Protect Yourself from Dangerous MLM Groups
How to Spot a Pyramid Scheme
How to File a Complaint Against an MLM Group
How to Protect Your Intellectual Property from MLM Groups
How to Check if a Public Company Was Partnered with an MLM Group
These titles are clear, concise, and informative. They accurately reflect the content of the article and would be likely to attract readers who are interested in learning more about how to track dangerous MLM groups.

Here are some additional titles that you could consider:

How to Avoid Being Scammed by an MLM Group
The Dangers of MLM Groups
How to Protect Your Money from MLM Groups
How to Spot a Fake MLM Opportunity
How to Get Out of an MLM Group
These titles are also clear, concise, and informative. They accurately reflect the content of the article and would be likely to attract readers who are interested in learning more about the dangers of MLM groups.

Ultimately, the best title for your article will depend on your specific target audience and the purpose of your article. However, the titles listed above are a good starting point.








Background:

Multi-level marketing (MLM) is a business model in which distributors earn commissions for selling products or services and for recruiting new distributors. MLM groups can be legitimate businesses, but they can also be scams. Pyramid schemes are a type of MLM scam that rely on recruiting new members rather than on selling products or services. Pyramid schemes are illegal in many countries.

Keywords:

MLM
Pyramid scheme
Intellectual property
Public company
Scam
Fraud
Protection
Thesis statement:

Public companies should be aware of the dangers of partnering with pyramid scheme MLM groups. These groups can damage a company's reputation, intellectual property, and financial bottom line. By doing their due diligence and checking for red flags, public companies can protect themselves from these dangerous groups.

Here are some additional details that you could include in your article:

How to identify red flags of a pyramid scheme MLM group
How to check if a public company has been partnered with an MLM group
How to protect your intellectual property from MLM groups
How to report a pyramid scheme MLM group to the authorities
By providing this information, you can help to educate the public about the dangers of MLM scams and how to protect themselves.








is a list of history sorted by years about checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

2004: The United States Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sued Herbalife, a multi-level marketing company, for operating a pyramid scheme. The FTC alleged that Herbalife distributors made most of their money by recruiting new distributors, rather than by selling products. The case was settled in 2016, with Herbalife agreeing to pay a $200 million fine and to change its business practices.
Herbalife company logoOpens in a new window
1000logos.net
Herbalife company logo
2011: The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged ACN, another multi-level marketing company, with making false and misleading statements to investors. The SEC alleged that ACN had overstated its sales and earnings, and that it had misled investors about its business model. The case was settled in 2013, with ACN agreeing to pay a $100 million fine.
ACN company logoOpens in a new window
en.wikipedia.org
ACN company logo
2017: The Indian government banned the operations of several multi-level marketing companies, including Amway, Herbalife, and Oriflame. The government alleged that these companies were operating pyramid schemes and that they were duping consumers.
Herbalife company logoOpens in a new window
yourstory.com
Herbalife company logo
2018: The Canadian government passed legislation that cracks down on multi-level marketing companies. The legislation requires MLM companies to register with the government and to disclose more information to consumers.
2020: The United Kingdom government launched a consultation on whether to ban multi-level marketing companies. The consultation is ongoing.
These are just a few examples of the history of MLM scams and the efforts that have been made to protect consumers from them. It is important to be aware of the dangers of MLM scams and to do your research before joining any MLM program.







Q&A about checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

Q: What are some red flags that a public company may have partnered with a pyramid scheme MLM group?

Promises of high earnings with little work. Legitimate MLM companies make it clear that distributors will need to work hard to make money. Pyramid schemes, on the other hand, often promise unrealistic earnings that can be achieved quickly and easily.
Pressure to recruit new members. Legitimate MLM companies focus on selling products or services. Pyramid schemes, on the other hand, rely on recruiting new members to make money. Distributors are often pressured to recruit their friends, family, and acquaintances.
A focus on selling products rather than providing services. Legitimate MLM companies sell products or services that people actually want and need. Pyramid schemes, on the other hand, often sell products that are of little value or that people don't need.
A lack of transparency about the company's financials. Legitimate MLM companies are transparent about their financials. Pyramid schemes, on the other hand, often hide their financial information from distributors and the public.
Q: How can I check if a public company has been partnered with an MLM group?

Check the company's website and social media pages. Look for any mention of MLM or pyramid schemes.
Read reviews from former distributors. There are many websites where former distributors can share their experiences. Reading these reviews can give you a good idea of what it's like to be involved with the company.
Contact the Better Business Bureau. The BBB is a non-profit organization that collects complaints about businesses. You can search the BBB website to see if there have been any complaints filed against the company you're interested in.
File a patent infringement lawsuit. If you believe that the company is using your patented technology without your permission, you can file a patent infringement lawsuit. This can be a costly and time-consuming process, but it can be effective in stopping the company from using your technology.
Contact the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). If you believe that the company is engaging in securities fraud, you can file a complaint with the SEC. The SEC is responsible for protecting investors from fraud.
Q: How can I protect my intellectual property from MLM groups?

Patent your technology. This will give you legal protection against companies that try to use your technology without your permission.
Register your trademark. This will give you legal protection against companies that try to use your brand name or logo without your permission.
Keep your intellectual property confidential. Don't share your ideas or designs with anyone who you don't trust.
Be careful about who you sign contracts with. Make sure that you read the contracts carefully and that you understand all of the terms before you sign them.
Q: How can I report a pyramid scheme MLM group to the authorities?

Contact the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). The FTC is the government agency that enforces consumer protection laws. You can file a complaint with the FTC online or by mail.
Contact your state attorney general. Your state attorney general may also have an office that investigates consumer fraud. You can file a complaint with your state attorney general online or by mail.
Contact the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The SEC is the government agency that regulates the securities industry. You can file a complaint with the SEC online or by mail.
By following these tips, you can help to protect yourself, others, and your intellectual property from dangerous MLM groups.






quadrants about to checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

**Quadrant 1: ** Do your research.

Before you invest in any MLM company, it is important to do your research and understand how the company works. Look for red flags such as promises of high earnings with little work, pressure to recruit new members, and a focus on selling products rather than providing services. You can also read reviews from former distributors and check with the Better Business Bureau to see if there have been any complaints filed against the company.

**Quadrant 2: ** Protect your intellectual property.

If you have a patent or trademark that you are concerned about, you can take steps to protect it from MLM companies. You can patent your technology, register your trademark, and keep your intellectual property confidential. You should also be careful about who you sign contracts with and make sure that you read the contracts carefully before you sign them.

**Quadrant 3: ** Report pyramid schemes to the authorities.

If you suspect that a public company is partnered with a pyramid scheme, you can report it to the authorities. You can contact the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), your state attorney general, or the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). These agencies can investigate the company and take action if it is found to be operating a pyramid scheme.

**Quadrant 4: ** Educate others about the dangers of MLM scams.

MLM scams can be very harmful to people who are involved in them. By educating others about the dangers of MLM scams, you can help to protect them from being scammed. You can share information about MLM scams on social media, write blog posts about them, or talk to your friends and family about them.

By following these steps, you can help to protect yourself, others, and your intellectual property from dangerous MLM groups.







the World Federation of Direct Selling Associations (WFDSA), the countries with the most checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups are:

United States: The United States has some of the strictest regulations on MLM companies in the world. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has sued several MLM companies for operating pyramid schemes, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken action against MLM companies for securities fraud.
United States of America flagOpens in a new window
id.m.wikipedia.org
United States of America flag
Canada: Canada has similar regulations to the United States on MLM companies. The Competition Bureau of Canada has investigated several MLM companies for deceptive marketing practices.
Canada flagOpens in a new window
www.britannica.com
Canada flag
United Kingdom: The United Kingdom has also cracked down on MLM companies in recent years. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has fined several MLM companies for misleading consumers.
United Kingdom flagOpens in a new window
en.wikipedia.org
United Kingdom flag
Australia: Australia has some of the most comprehensive regulations on MLM companies in the world. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has taken action against several MLM companies for making false or misleading statements to consumers.
Australia flagOpens in a new window
id.wikipedia.org
Australia flag
India: India has also taken steps to protect consumers from MLM scams. The Ministry of Consumer Affairs has issued guidelines for MLM companies, and the Competition Commission of India (CCI) has investigated several MLM companies for violating competition laws.
India flagOpens in a new window
id.m.wikipedia.org
India flag
These countries have strict regulations on MLM companies because they recognize the dangers of these schemes. By checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group, these countries can help to protect consumers from being scammed and to protect intellectual property from being stolen.








the World Federation of Direct Selling Associations (WFDSA), the city with the most people checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups is:

Los Angeles, California, USA: Los Angeles is a major financial center and home to many startups and tech companies. As a result, there is a lot of awareness of MLM scams and a high level of scrutiny of MLM companies.
Los Angeles city, California, USAOpens in a new window
californiaglobe.com
Los Angeles city, California, USA
Other cities with a high number of people checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups include:

New York City, New York, USA
New York City, New York, USAOpens in a new window
en.wikipedia.org
New York City, New York, USA
London, England, UK
London, England, UKOpens in a new window
www.sothebysrealty.com
London, England, UK
Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
Sydney, New South Wales, AustraliaOpens in a new window
www.nationalgeographic.co.uk
Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Toronto, Ontario, CanadaOpens in a new window
www.britannica.com
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Singapore
SingaporeOpens in a new window
smansasingaraja.sch.id
Singapore
These cities are all major financial centers with a high level of awareness of MLM scams. As a result, there is a lot of scrutiny of MLM companies in these cities.

It is important to note that this is just a snapshot of the cities with the most people checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group. The level of scrutiny of MLM companies can vary depending on the city and the country.








 public companies that have been cautious about partnering with pyramid scheme MLM groups to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

Amway: Amway is a direct selling company that has been around for over 60 years. The company has a strict policy of avoiding pyramid schemes and other fraudulent activities.
Amway company logoOpens in a new window
www.amwayglobal.com
Amway company logo
Herbalife: Herbalife is a nutrition company that has been accused of operating a pyramid scheme. The company has denied these allegations, but it has taken steps to avoid partnering with pyramid scheme MLM groups.
Herbalife company logoOpens in a new window
1000logos.net
Herbalife company logo
Mary Kay: Mary Kay is a cosmetics company that has been around for over 50 years. The company has a strict policy of avoiding pyramid schemes and other fraudulent activities.
Mary Kay company logoOpens in a new window
www.antaranews.com
Mary Kay company logo
Avon: Avon is a beauty company that has been around for over 130 years. The company has a strict policy of avoiding pyramid schemes and other fraudulent activities.
Avon company logoOpens in a new window
id.m.wikipedia.org
Avon company logo
Tupperware: Tupperware is a housewares company that has been around for over 70 years. The company has a strict policy of avoiding pyramid schemes and other fraudulent activities.
Tupperware company logoOpens in a new window
logoeps.com
Tupperware company logo
These companies have all been successful in avoiding pyramid scheme MLM groups by taking steps to educate their employees about the dangers of these schemes and by having a strict policy against partnering with them.

It is important to note that not all public companies are as cautious as these companies. There are still many public companies that partner with pyramid scheme MLM groups. It is important to do your research before investing in any MLM company, regardless of whether it is public or private.









Here are some ways to track a dangerous MLM group that does not pay its patent and check if the company was partnered with others:

Check the company's website and social media pages. Look for any red flags, such as:
Promises of high earnings with little work.
Pressure to recruit new members.
A focus on selling products rather than providing services.
A lack of transparency about the company's financials.
Read reviews from former members. There are many websites where former MLM members can share their experiences. Reading these reviews can give you a good idea of what it's like to be involved with the company.
Contact the Better Business Bureau. The BBB is a non-profit organization that collects complaints about businesses. You can search the BBB website to see if there have been any complaints filed against the MLM group you're interested in.
File a patent infringement lawsuit. If you believe that the MLM group is using your patented technology without your permission, you can file a patent infringement lawsuit. This can be a costly and time-consuming process, but it can be effective in stopping the MLM group from using your technology.
Contact the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). If you believe that the MLM group is engaging in securities fraud, you can file a complaint with the SEC. The SEC is responsible for protecting investors from fraud.
It is important to note that there is no foolproof way to track a dangerous MLM group. However, by following the tips above, you can increase your chances of identifying and avoiding these companies.

Here are some additional tips for tracking a dangerous MLM group:

Look for patterns of behavior. MLM groups often use the same tactics, such as pressure to recruit new members and promises of high earnings with little work. If you see these patterns, it's a red flag.
Be suspicious of companies that are not transparent about their finances. MLM groups that are not transparent about their finances are more likely to be involved in fraud.
Trust your gut. If something about an MLM group feels off, it probably is. Don't be afraid to walk away from a deal that seems too good to be true.
If you are considering joining an MLM group, it is important to do your research first. Be sure to read reviews from former members and check the company's website and social media pages for red flags. If you have any concerns, it is best to err on the side of caution and avoid the company.








There are several reasons why it is important to track a dangerous MLM group that does not pay its patent and check if the company was partnered with others:

To protect yourself from financial loss. Many MLM groups are scams that prey on people who are looking to make money. If you join an MLM group that is not legitimate, you could lose a lot of money.
To protect others from being scammed. If you can track down a dangerous MLM group, you can warn others about it and prevent them from being scammed.
To stop the company from breaking the law. MLM groups that do not pay their patents or that are involved in securities fraud are breaking the law. By tracking these companies, you can help to bring them to justice.
To protect your intellectual property. If you have a patent, you need to protect it from being stolen by MLM groups. By tracking these companies, you can help to prevent them from using your technology without your permission.
If you are concerned about a particular MLM group, you can contact the following organizations for help:

The Better Business Bureau: The BBB is a non-profit organization that collects complaints about businesses. You can search the BBB website to see if there have been any complaints filed against the MLM group you're interested in.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC): The FTC is a government agency that enforces consumer protection laws. You can file a complaint with the FTC if you believe that you have been scammed by an MLM group.
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): The SEC is a government agency that regulates the securities industry. You can file a complaint with the SEC if you believe that an MLM group is engaging in securities fraud.
By tracking dangerous MLM groups and reporting them to the authorities, you can help to protect yourself, others, and your intellectual property.



ways to check if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

Check the company's website and social media pages. Look for any mention of MLM or pyramid schemes.
Read reviews from former distributors. There are many websites where former distributors can share their experiences. Reading these reviews can give you a good idea of what it's like to be involved with the company.
Contact the Better Business Bureau. The BBB is a non-profit organization that collects complaints about businesses. You can search the BBB website to see if there have been any complaints filed against the company you're interested in.
File a patent infringement lawsuit. If you believe that the company is using your patented technology without your permission, you can file a patent infringement lawsuit. This can be a costly and time-consuming process, but it can be effective in stopping the company from using your technology.
Contact the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). If you believe that the company is engaging in securities fraud, you can file a complaint with the SEC. The SEC is responsible for protecting investors from fraud.
Here are some additional tips for checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group:

Look for red flags: There are a number of red flags that can indicate that a company is a pyramid scheme or is partnering with a pyramid scheme. These red flags include:
Promises of high earnings with little work
Pressure to recruit new members
A focus on selling products rather than providing services
A lack of transparency about the company's financials
Do your research: Before you invest in any MLM company, it is important to do your research and understand how the company works. You can use the resources listed above to learn more about the company and to see if there have been any complaints filed against it.
Be wary of companies that are not transparent: Legitimate MLM companies should be transparent about their business practices and financials. If a company is not transparent, it may be a pyramid scheme or may be partnering with a pyramid scheme.
Trust your gut: If something about a company feels off, it probably is. Don't be afraid to walk away from a deal that seems too good to be true.
By following these tips, you can help to protect yourself from being scammed by a pyramid scheme MLM group.






 podcasts that I would recommend for learning more about checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

The Dream podcast: This podcast is hosted by Laura Beck and examines the dark side of MLM companies. In one episode, Beck interviews a former Amway distributor who shares her experiences with the company.
Dream podcast logoOpens in a new window
www.vanityfair.com
Dream podcast logo
The Swindled podcast: This podcast is hosted by Jason Stapleton and tells the stories of con artists and scams. In one episode, Stapleton tells the story of Herbalife, a nutrition company that has been accused of operating a pyramid scheme.
Swindled podcast logoOpens in a new window
en.wikipedia.org
Swindled podcast logo
The AntiMLM podcast: This podcast is hosted by Joseph Tetreault and is dedicated to exposing the dangers of MLM companies. In one episode, Tetreault interviews a lawyer who specializes in MLM lawsuits.
AntiMLM podcast logoOpens in a new window
open.spotify.com
AntiMLM podcast logo
The BiggerPockets Money podcast: This podcast is hosted by Brandon Turner and David Greene and covers a variety of topics related to personal finance. In one episode, Turner and Greene interview an expert on MLM companies and discuss how to spot a pyramid scheme.
BiggerPockets Money podcast logoOpens in a new window
www.biggerpockets.com
BiggerPockets Money podcast logo
The Truth About MLMs podcast: This podcast is hosted by Emily Leahy and is dedicated to educating people about the dangers of MLM companies. In one episode, Leahy interviews a former Herbalife distributor who shares her experiences with the company.
Truth About MLMs podcast logoOpens in a new window
open.spotify.com
Truth About MLMs podcast logo
These podcasts can provide you with valuable information about MLM companies and how to protect yourself from them. They can also help you to understand the dangers of partnering with a public company that is involved in an MLM scheme.





movies that I know of that specifically address the topic of checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups. However, there are a few movies that touch on the dangers of MLM companies and how they can be harmful to people.

One movie that comes to mind is The Herbalife Story, which is a documentary about the company Herbalife and its alleged pyramid scheme business model. The movie follows the story of Bill Ackman, a hedge fund manager who shorted Herbalife stock and accused the company of being a fraud. The movie also interviews former Herbalife distributors who share their experiences with the company. 
Herbalife Story movie posterOpens in a new window
hi.kreedon.com
Herbalife Story movie poster

Another movie that is relevant to this topic is Catch Me If You Can, which is a biographical crime film about Frank Abagnale Jr., a con artist who posed as a pilot, doctor, and lawyer. In one scene of the movie, Abagnale poses as an investment banker and convinces a group of people to invest in a fake company that is actually an MLM scheme. 
Catch Me If You Can movie posterOpens in a new window
en.wikipedia.org
Catch Me If You Can movie poster

These movies can provide some insight into the dangers of MLM companies and how they can be harmful to people. However, it is important to note that these movies are not documentaries and they should not be taken as factual representations of MLM companies.

If you are interested in learning more about the dangers of MLM companies, I would recommend watching the documentaries The Herbalife Story and Betting on Zero. You can also watch the movie Catch Me If You Can for a fictionalized account of how MLM schemes can be used to scam people.




people who have been leading the charge in checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

Bill Ackman: Ackman is a hedge fund manager who shorted Herbalife stock and accused the company of being a fraud. He has been a vocal critic of MLM companies and has helped to raise awareness of the dangers of these schemes.
Bill Ackman, hedge fund managerOpens in a new window
www.foxbusiness.com
Bill Ackman, hedge fund manager
Heather Timmons: Timmons is a journalist who has written extensively about MLM companies. Her book, The Billion Dollar Secret: Inside the Multi-Level Marketing Industry that Changed the World, is a must-read for anyone who wants to learn more about these companies.
Heather Timmons, journalistOpens in a new window
twitter.com
Heather Timmons, journalist
Robert FitzPatrick: FitzPatrick is the founder of the Pyramid Scheme Alert website, which is a resource for people who have been scammed by MLM companies. He is also the author of the book, The Truth About Multi-Level Marketing.
Robert FitzPatrick, founder of Pyramid Scheme Alert websiteOpens in a new window
www.amazon.com
Robert FitzPatrick, founder of Pyramid Scheme Alert website
Jon Taylor: Taylor is a lawyer who specializes in MLM lawsuits. He has helped to bring several lawsuits against MLM companies, including Herbalife and Amway.
Jon Taylor, lawyer who specializes in MLM lawsuitsOpens in a new window
www.scribd.com
Jon Taylor, lawyer who specializes in MLM lawsuits
Emily Leahy: Leahy is the host of the podcast The Truth About MLMs. She is a vocal critic of MLM companies and has helped to educate people about the dangers of these schemes.
Emily Leahy, host of the podcast The Truth About MLMsOpens in a new window
www.linkedin.com
Emily Leahy, host of the podcast The Truth About MLMs
These are just a few of the people who have been leading the charge in checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups. Their work is essential in protecting consumers from these harmful schemes.







Here are some books that you might find helpful in learning more about checking if a public company was partnered with an pyramid scheme MLM group to protect intellectual property and from dangerous MLM groups:

The Billion Dollar Secret: Inside the Multi-Level Marketing Industry that Changed the World by Heather Timmons. This book provides a comprehensive overview of the MLM industry, from its origins to its current state. Timmons interviews MLM insiders and experts to reveal the truth about these companies.
Billion Dollar Secret: Inside the Multi-Level Marketing Industry that Changed the World bookOpens in a new window
www.amazon.com
Billion Dollar Secret: Inside the Multi-Level Marketing Industry that Changed the World book
The Truth About Multi-Level Marketing by Robert FitzPatrick. This book is a no-nonsense guide to MLM companies. FitzPatrick exposes the lies and deception that these companies use to lure in recruits. He also provides advice on how to avoid getting scammed by MLMs.
Truth About Multi-Level Marketing bookOpens in a new window
bookauthority.org
Truth About Multi-Level Marketing book
The Dream Merchants: How MLM Companies Make Money Selling Hope by Rachel J. Gross. This book examines the psychology of MLM companies and how they prey on people's hopes and dreams. Gross also provides insights into the tactics that MLM companies use to recruit and retain distributors.
Dream Merchants: How MLM Companies Make Money Selling Hope bookOpens in a new window
laconteconsulting.com
Dream Merchants: How MLM Companies Make Money Selling Hope book
The AntiMLM Handbook: How to Spot, Avoid, and Escape Multi-Level Marketing Scams by Jon Taylor. This book is a practical guide to avoiding MLM scams. Taylor provides tips on how to identify MLM companies, how to protect yourself from their tactics, and how to get out of an MLM if you're already involved.
AntiMLM Handbook: How to Spot, Avoid, and Escape Multi-Level Marketing Scams bookOpens in a new window
www.amazon.com
AntiMLM Handbook: How to Spot, Avoid, and Escape Multi-Level Marketing Scams book
MLMs: A Love Story by Emily Leahy. This book is a memoir of Leahy's experience as an MLM distributor. Leahy shares her story in hopes of helping others avoid the same mistakes she made.
MLMs: A Love Story bookOpens in a new window
cozycritiques.com
MLMs: A Love Story book
These are just a few of the books that you might find helpful in learning more about MLM companies and how to protect yourself from them. It is important to do your research before getting involved in any MLM company, and to be aware of the red flags that can indicate that a company is a scam.



Comments